I went with the Vokey gap wedge.  For me, I was looking more for control, spin, and versatility than I was distance.  I felt the Vokey wedge gave me that.  I really don't hit a lot of 100% power gap wedge shots (which is where I feel the AP2 GW would help…

I think you sort of answered your own question.  If you can cover the gap between a 52 and your PW, then go for it.  For me, I liked having a little less loft on my gap wedge to limit the number of times I had to hit 3/4 PW shots.  But it sounds like you…